Elderly woman in supported living reading a book with nurse

Balancing Compliance with Compassion: Overcoming Challenges to Person-Centred Care in Supported Living

Luke Flannery, Author

Healthcare environments are diverse, with each setting presenting unique challenges, especially when it comes to managing patient behaviours. From the fast-paced intensity of emergency departments to the sensitive nature of elderly care and mental health units, healthcare professionals are often required to adjust their approach to behaviour management to ensure safety and positive outcomes for both patients and staff. In this article, we explore the tailored strategies that can be applied across various healthcare settings to address challenging behaviours effectively, drawing on Timian’s principles of positive behaviour management.

Understanding the Context: Why One-Size-Fits-All Doesn’t Work

In healthcare, it’s essential to recognize that a standardised approach to behaviour management is often ineffective. Each healthcare setting comes with its own unique stressors, patient demographics, and situational dynamics. A behaviour management strategy that works well in a psychiatric unit may not be suitable in an elderly care home or emergency department. This is why adaptable, context-specific approaches are crucial for managing challenging behaviours.

At Timian, we emphasise flexible, positive behaviour management techniques that are tailored to the specific needs of each setting. By focusing on proactive de-escalation, communication, and trauma-informed care, healthcare professionals can create safer environments that are conducive to healing and recovery.

behaviour Management in Emergency Departments

Emergency departments (EDs) are high-pressure environments where healthcare staff are often faced with patients experiencing acute distress, pain, or confusion. The fast pace and unpredictability of EDs can exacerbate challenging behaviours, especially among patients who may be disoriented or fearful.

Strategies for Managing behaviour in EDs:

  • Rapid De-escalation Techniques: Staff should be trained in quick, effective de-escalation methods to calm agitated patients. This may include using calm, reassuring language and providing clear information to reduce anxiety.
  • Creating a Calming Environment: While EDs are inherently busy, small changes—like reducing noise levels or providing privacy where possible—can significantly impact patient behaviour.
  • Staff Preparedness: Regular training in breakaway techniques and conflict resolution can empower staff to handle aggressive situations confidently and safely, protecting both patients and themselves.

Addressing Challenging behaviours in Mental Health Units

In mental health settings, patients may present with behaviours stemming from a variety of underlying conditions, including anxiety, psychosis, or trauma histories. Here, the focus should be on understanding the root causes of behaviour and adopting a compassionate, trauma-informed approach.

Strategies for Mental Health Settings:

  • Individualized behaviour Plans: Developing personalized behaviour management plans based on each patient’s history, triggers, and coping mechanisms is crucial. This allows staff to respond to behaviours with empathy and understanding.
  • Trauma-Informed Care: Recognizing that many patients in mental health units have experienced trauma, staff should prioritize trust-building and avoid practices that could re-traumatize patients.
  • Continuous Staff Training: Training staff to recognize signs of escalating behaviour early can prevent crises. Techniques such as active listening, validating patients’ feelings, and providing choices can help reduce feelings of powerlessness and aggression.

Positive behaviour Management in Elderly Care

Elderly care settings often involve patients with cognitive impairments, such as dementia, which can lead to confusion, frustration, and aggressive behaviours. The challenge here is to manage these behaviours while preserving the dignity of residents.

Strategies for Elderly Care:

  • Person-Centered Approaches: Understanding the individual’s life history, preferences, and routines can help staff identify triggers and implement calming strategies that are respectful of their personal background.
  • Non-Verbal Communication: Many elderly patients may have difficulty expressing themselves verbally. Training staff in reading body language and using gentle, non-verbal communication techniques can be effective in preventing agitation.
  • Environment Modification: Adjusting the physical environment to reduce overstimulation—such as lowering noise levels, using soft lighting, and providing familiar, comforting items—can help soothe residents and minimize disruptive behaviours.

Bridging the Gap: Tailoring Training for Diverse Healthcare Settings

While the core principles of positive behaviour management—such as de-escalation, trauma-informed care, and compassionate communication—are universally applicable, the way these principles are implemented should be tailored to the specific needs of each setting. Timian’s training programs are designed to equip healthcare staff with adaptable skills that can be customized for their unique environments.

Key Components of Timian’s Approach:

  • Blended Learning Models: Timian’s training incorporates both e-learning and hands-on practice, allowing staff to learn and apply techniques that are most relevant to their specific healthcare context.
  • Scenario-Based Training: By using real-life scenarios that staff are likely to encounter in their specific settings, training becomes more practical and directly applicable.
  • Ongoing Support and Development: Continuous professional development ensures that staff stay current with best practices, enhancing their ability to provide safe and compassionate care across various healthcare environments.

Conclusion: The Importance of Flexibility in behaviour Management

Adapting behaviour management strategies to the specific needs of different healthcare settings is essential for both patient well-being and staff safety. By embracing a flexible, positive approach to managing challenging behaviours, healthcare leaders can create environments that are not only compliant with regulatory standards but also compassionate and supportive.

At Timian, we understand the complexities of behaviour management in healthcare and are committed to providing training that empowers healthcare professionals to deliver the best care possible, no matter the setting. For more information on how Timian’s tailored training programs can benefit your organisation, visit Timian Learning and Development.

Sign-up to receive our helpful learning guidebooks

Further Reading From Timian